Big Ten Playoff Chaos: UCLA, Indiana, and Ohio State Suffer Upset Losses in Week 12
Upset losses by top-ranked Big Ten teams have complicated the playoff picture, benefiting Oregon and raising questions about the selection process.
By Daniela Kelly ·

The Big Ten Conference experienced a dramatic turn of events this past Saturday as three of its top-ranked teams fell to unranked opponents with losing conference records. No. 4 UCLA, No. 8 Indiana, and No. 14 Ohio State all suffered defeats, creating a complex and perilous landscape for the College Football Playoff selection committee.
Ohio State’s 31-28 loss at Nebraska marked the latest disappointment in a season that began with high aspirations. Receiver Jeremiah Smith delivered a standout performance with six catches for 165 yards and two touchdowns, yet the result leaves questions about his Heisman Trophy prospects if the team fails to advance to the playoffs.
UCLA’s defeat was particularly concerning due to an injury to quarterback Ty Dieffenbach, who was carted off the field during the first overtime of a triple-overtime loss to Michigan. With starter Nico Iamaleava already out for the season, the Bruins face a significant drop-off in talent. A win against USC next week would secure the Big Ten title game, but a loss would leave their fate in the hands of other teams.
Indiana found itself in a precarious position after losing 27-24 to Washington in overtime. The Hoosiers had led twice in the fourth quarter before the upset. While a win over Purdue next week would bring their record to 10-2, the result does little to bolster their ranking against stronger competition.
The chaos of the weekend benefited Oregon the most. After falling to a 4-3 record earlier in the season, the Ducks are now 8-3. A victory against Washington next week would advance them to the Big Ten championship game, where they could secure an automatic playoff berth.
Meanwhile, Miami clinched a spot in the ACC title game with a 28-20 win over Virginia Tech, but coach Mario Cristobal expressed frustration with the team's performance. He noted that they did not play to their standard. The good news is that receiver Malachi Toney is expected to return in about a week and a half, which could significantly boost their offensive potential.
The Heisman Trophy race has shifted as Ohio State fades from contention. Miami’s Darian Mensah leads the nation in quarterback rating and completion percentage, but Malachi Toney is considered the team's best player. Other candidates include Georgia’s Gunner Stockton, Utah’s Devon Dampier, Notre Dame’s CJ Carr, and Wake Forest’s Gio Lopez, each with distinct statistical strengths.
In other notable results, Boise State’s playoff hopes were derailed by a controversial decision by coach Spencer Danielson to go for a fourth down instead of punting. The play failed, allowing San Diego State to win on a game-winning field goal. This loss opens the door for other Group of Five teams, such as Louisiana Tech and New Mexico, to vie for a playoff spot.
The weekend also highlighted the ongoing debate regarding conference strength and playoff selection criteria. With so many upsets, analysts are questioning whether the current system fairly evaluates teams based on recent results versus historical prestige. The selection committee will now face difficult decisions as the regular season winds down.
As the season progresses, the focus shifts to how these results will be interpreted by voters and the selection committee. The unpredictability of college football remains evident, with parity continuing to define the current landscape.
More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?






