Shapiro and Garrity Clash Over Data Centers
A shift in public opinion has turned infrastructure projects into a central issue for the November gubernatorial race.
By Yasmin Parker ·

Gov. Josh Shapiro and state Treasurer Stacy Garrity have reversed their public stances on data center development as voters in Pennsylvania grow wary of new construction. The reversal comes with the gubernatorial election scheduled for Tuesday.
A year ago, Amazon announced a $20 billion investment in the state for new data centers. Shapiro declared Pennsylvania would be all in on artificial intelligence and the necessary infrastructure. Garrity, appearing on a radio show, called rural areas perfect locations for these economic projects.
Both candidates have since moderated their positions in response to local backlash. They have exchanged attack ads and questioned each other's regulatory records. The campaign now frames data centers as a test of leadership on predatory development.
Garrity's campaign released a controversial ad featuring a deepfake of Shapiro. The AI-generated image of Shapiro states that the ad was created with AI thanks to big beautiful data centers. He claims to have fast-tracked the projects after receiving $5 million in political contributions from the industry.
Shapiro signed an executive order in August that reinforces local decision-making. The order requires developers to meet stricter standards for energy use and transparency. Garrity has proposed a temporary pause on new projects to allow communities time to debate the issue and update zoning laws.
Public opinion has shifted sharply against expansion. A Quinnipiac poll from July found that 76 percent of likely voters are following news about AI data centers closely. Another 74 percent said they would oppose construction in their communities.
There are currently about 70 data center projects in Pennsylvania that are proposed, under construction, or in preliminary activity. More than 20 additional proposals have been withdrawn, delayed, or rejected due to local pushback, according to an independent dashboard tracking hyperscale projects.
Residents are making their voices heard at local hearings. In Upper Hanover, Montgomery County, one developer withdrew a proposal this month after underestimating public outcry. In the Poconos, another developer offered residents $10,000 checks to secure support. Legal battles over zoning are also emerging, including a contested case in Upper Merion Township.
Supporters of data centers argue that negative polling is misleading. A survey by Susquehanna Polling and Research, commissioned by the American Infrastructure Alliance, found that initial support stands at 36 percent. However, that number rises to 80 percent when developers outline specific commitments to protect resources and address energy costs. Jim Lee, president and CEO of Susquehanna, said voters want to know if development will be responsible.
Ben Berger, a political scientist at Swarthmore College, notes that concrete local stakes drive civic engagement. He compares the current situation to the long-running conflict over fracking and natural gas in Pennsylvania. That issue eventually receded from the forefront of state politics after initial activism peaked. Berger said the scope of conflict matters, and opponents win by widening it to include packed meetings and statewide networks.





