AdvertiseDonate
Live Newsline · 1101 West 34th Street, Austin, TX 78705

Jilly Cooper accused of extensive plagiarism in 1978 novel

The late bestselling author is alleged to have lifted at least 35 passages from two other novels, prompting her family to consider legal action.

By Yasmin Parker ·

Illustration for: Jilly Cooper accused of extensive plagiarism in 1978 novel
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

The late British author Dame Jilly Cooper has been accused of committing extensive and deliberate plagiarism in her 1978 novel, Prudence. The allegations suggest that the bestselling writer lifted significant portions of text from two other works, specifically The Serial by Cyra McFadden and The Franchise Affair by Josephine Tey. The claims were detailed in a recent report by the Observer newspaper.

According to the investigation, Cooper allegedly lifted at least 35 passages from McFadden’s novel alone. Prudence was the fifth book in Cooper’s romance series. McFadden, who passed away in 2024, is survived by her daughter, Caroline McFadden. The daughter expressed strong dissatisfaction with the discovery, describing the act as unconscionable.

Caroline McFadden stated that it is difficult to accept that her mother’s work was stolen to generate profit. She said, "It absolutely boils my blood to think of someone stealing my mother’s work because I know how hard she worked at her craft." McFadden is currently evaluating legal options to address the matter. She hopes that the scrutiny will extend to Cooper’s other works to determine if this was a recurring pattern.

The Observer highlighted several striking similarities between the two texts. In The Serial, published as a weekly newspaper serial in the United States before becoming a book in May 1977, the character Kate discusses her relationship with her ex-husband Harvey. She describes wanting an open relationship based on trust and growth, while he focused on having his jockey shorts ironed.

A nearly identical exchange appears in Prudence. The character Berenice, an American feminist, makes a similar statement to her ex-husband. She notes that she wanted an open living relationship based on trust and growth, while he only cared about his ironed jockey shorts. The publication also cited another instance where a character in The Serial advises another to cut out nine-to-five work and get in touch with the universe. A very similar line of dialogue is attributed to Berenice in Cooper’s novel.

The investigation into Prudence began after a reader noticed similarities between Cooper’s text and Tey’s 1948 novel, The Franchise Affair. The Observer alleged that Cooper lifted directly from chapter 22 of Tey’s book, both in the structure of the narrative and in specific word choices. Josephine Tey died in 1952 and did not leave any heirs.

Cooper had previously acknowledged McFadden’s work. In a 1982 column for the Mail on Sunday, she praised The Serial for its parody of modern feminism. She described feeling tremendously comforted upon discovering a passage in the book, which she called a marvellously funny send-up of American trendies in the late 1970s.

Cooper was a highly successful author who sold more than 11 million copies of her books in the United Kingdom. She was awarded a damehood in the 2024 New Year Honours for her services to literature and charity. Currently, Disney+ is airing the second series of Rivals, a television adaptation of her most famous work. The show features TV industry intrigue and romantic scenes set in the Cotswolds countryside, referred to as Rutshire in the series.

The author died last October. An inquest held in 2025 concluded that she suffered a fatal head injury after a fall at her home in Gloucestershire. She was found by family members on 4 October 2025 and passed away in the hospital the next day.

The Guardian has reached out to Cooper’s agent, Felicity Blunt at Curtis Brown, as well as her publisher, Penguin, for comment. According to the Observer, both parties have declined to provide a response to the allegations.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Live Newsline in your inboxYour daily read on the news. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Live Newsline in your inboxYour daily read on the news. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.