Pip benefit review recommends major overhaul rather than abolition for under-25s
A government review led by social security minister Stephen Timms will propose significant reforms to the personal independence payment, contradicting a recent report that called for the benefit to be scrapped for young adults.
By Amir Shah ·

A long-anticipated review of the personal independence payment system is set to recommend a comprehensive overhaul this week. This proposal comes just one week after a separate report suggested that the benefit should be partly scrapped for adults under the age of 25. The timing places Prime Minister Andy Burnham in the position of making one of his most politically sensitive decisions to date.
The final report, produced by a committee co-led by Social Security Minister Stephen Timms, is expected to be published as soon as Tuesday. The recommendations appear closely aligned with a draft set of proposals that surfaced in September. Those earlier drafts called for significant changes to the assessment system to better accommodate medical conditions that fluctuate over time.
While the Timms review advocates for retaining the Pip system for all age groups, the Milburn report published last week took a different approach. That report recommended removing Pip for adults under 25 and replacing it with an additional cost allowance. This change was part of a broader strategy to support job-based assistance for young people not in education, employment, or training.
Government officials have attempted to minimize the perceived conflict between the two reports. They noted that the Milburn review was commissioned after the Timms process had already begun. Additionally, officials highlighted that approximately 90 percent of the current Pip caseload involves individuals over the age of 25. Despite this, the broad nature of Timms’ recommendations means Burnham and his cabinet must now navigate a series of complex decisions on a deeply sensitive subject.
The political stakes are high following the collapse of previous Pip plans under Keir Starmer in 2025. Those earlier proposals, which were based around five billion pounds in cuts, were abandoned after a major rebellion from Labour MPs. This history has made the current situation particularly delicate for the government.
Disability campaigners and charities expressed widespread shock when the Milburn report recommended scrapping Pip and universal credit health benefit payments for under-25s. The intent was to boost jobs and training for young people outside of standard pathways. However, some members of the Timms review board have reportedly expressed concern over the scale of Milburn’s proposals, which would reduce spending on young people by 3.6 billion pounds.
The review steering group is co-chaired by Timms and disability rights advocates Clenton Farquharson and Sharon Brennan. The majority of the group’s twelve members have lived experience of disability or long-term health conditions. One source told The Guardian that some board members are really concerned about the implications of the conflicting reports.
The upcoming report will outline both short-term overhauls within the current spending round and longer-term structural changes. Many specific details for the longer-term reforms will require ministerial decisions before legislation is introduced next year. The prime minister faces ongoing pressure from the Conservative party to reduce the overall cost of working-age benefits, though he has previously pushed back against what he described as crude cuts that often create costs elsewhere.
Ministers have framed the Timms review as a groundbreaking co-produced policy initiative designed to restore trust among disabled people. The interim report from July and subsequent findings confirmed a consensus that Pip was no longer fit for purpose. It emphasized that while some claimants might receive in-kind awards such as services or aids in the future, cash payments remain the foundation of the reformed benefit.
The review insisted that any reformed benefit would be non-means tested and designed with disabled people to ensure it works before rollout. There was no mention of scrapping Pip for under-25s or other specific age groups. Although most disability charities had been optimistic about the Timms review, the timing and scope of the Milburn report have somewhat dented that confidence.






