LSU Football: The $40 Million Roster That Missed the Playoff
A six-and-four record and a projected absence from the College Football Playoff have prompted a CFB analyst to question whether the Tigers' massive NIL spending actually bought quality depth.
By Yasmin Parker ·

The 2026 season for the LSU Tigers has deviated sharply from the projections that accompanied the hiring of Lane Kiffin from Ole Miss. The Bayou Bengals entered the year with a roster estimated at between $40 million and $50 million in Name, Image, and Likeness value. This financial figure positioned the team among the most expensive in college football and set high expectations for an immediate national title push.
By mid-November 2026, the Tigers stand at 6-4. That record has eliminated them from contention for the SEC Championship and projects them to miss the College Football Playoff entirely. Even if LSU wins its upcoming games against top-ten Tennessee and Arkansas, the team's standing in the CFP polls is unlikely to change enough to secure a spot.
The front office assembled a high-profile staff to support Kiffin. That group included Blake Baker, a defensive coordinator widely regarded as one of the best in the sport. The combination of a premier head coach, an elite support staff, and a massive portal budget led many to assume a first-year success was guaranteed.
College football commentator Josh Pate disagrees with that assumption. Pate, a popular YouTube host, replied to a viewer question by sarcastically noting that Kiffin enters next year on the hot seat. He clarified that he is not asking anyone to feel sorry for the coach, but he believes the spending strategy was flawed.
Pate argues that LSU recklessly spent money in the transfer portal to build a team capable of competing for a national title immediately. He notes that the specific dollar amount is less important than the quality of the players acquired. He asks if the same roster paid $28 million would perform differently, concluding that it is the same group of athletes regardless of the price tag.
The analyst points out that the Tigers likely overpaid for average talent on the depth chart. While the portal class included several high-quality players, they filled gaps rather than providing superior depth. Pate identifies the most critical failure as the quarterback position, noting that there is no star player at that spot despite the high overall cost of the roster.
Pate’s current assessment aligns with a prediction he made in July 2026. At that time, he stated that the Tigers would miss the playoff in their first season under Kiffin. That early take caused frustration among LSU fans who believed the financial investment ensured a successful launch.
The program now faces a second year with heightened expectations. Kiffin commands a substantial salary and has been given the resources to avoid such a first-year stumble. If the team fails to secure a playoff berth again in 2027, the pressure on the coach to deliver results will be at its peak.






