AdvertiseDonate
Live Newsline · 1101 West 34th Street, Austin, TX 78705

Generations of Palestinians Face Legal Limbo in Egyptian Village

In a northern Egyptian village, generations of Palestinian refugees continue to face bureaucratic and financial barriers to education and healthcare, living in a state of legal limbo despite decades of residence.

By Yasmin Parker ·

Illustration for: Generations of Palestinians Face Legal Limbo in Egyptian Village
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

In the village of Geziret Fadel, located in Egypt’s Sharqiya province, a community of Palestinian refugees continues to navigate a complex legal status that has persisted for decades. The village, situated about an hour northeast of Cairo, is home to approximately 4,000 Palestinians who have lived in the area since the displacement associated with the creation of the State of Israel in 1948.

Shamma Abu Hussein, a 90-year-old resident, is potentially the last person in the village who lived in what is now Israel. She fled from Beersheba with her family during the hostilities of 1948, an event Palestinians refer to as the Nakba, or catastrophe. Her family’s journey involved traveling on camels for several days without food or water until they reached Egypt, where her mother passed away during the trek.

Abu Hussein expressed concern that the current war against Hamas in Gaza, which began after the October 7, 2023, invasion and massacre, may lead to further displacement. She noted that rhetoric from some far-right Israeli ministers calling for the expulsion of Gazans has revived fears that history is repeating itself. She described the desire to uproot people from their homes as a continuation of the suffering her family has endured for generations.

Many residents of Geziret Fadel, including those born in Egypt, face significant bureaucratic hurdles because they are treated as foreigners rather than citizens. Selmi Soliman al-Namouli, a 63-year-old agricultural laborer and father of ten, explained that while he and his children were born in Egypt, he is treated as a foreigner when dealing with official paperwork. He stated that the cost of residency renewals, which must be paid in US dollars, along with school fees, places a heavy financial burden on his family.

This financial pressure has impacted educational opportunities for the younger generation. Al-Namouli said he could not afford to send his daughter Asmaa to university despite her academic promise. Similarly, his nephew Farid Khaled al-Namouli, 25, abandoned his higher education goals after encountering obstacles with administrative requirements. He left school and found work in a local clothing shop, a common outcome for many residents who never completed their education.

Lubnah Shomali of the Palestinian refugee rights organization BADIL noted that these challenges are widespread among Palestinians in Egypt. Researchers estimate that around 50,000 displaced Palestinians lived in Egypt before the latest Gaza war, with more than 100,000 additional arrivals since the conflict began. Shomali described the situation as an ongoing Nakba, arguing that the displacement continues and that generations of Palestinians are trapped in a coercive environment that limits access to basic rights.

Egyptian officials have maintained that the country provides medical care and education to Palestinian refugees and opposes permanent displacement. However, regulations have tightened since the late 1970s, following the assassination of Egyptian culture minister Yusuf Sibai and Egypt’s peace treaty with Israel. Previously, under President Gamal Abdel Nasser, Palestinians enjoyed access to education and employment similar to that of Egyptian citizens.

Dawn Chatty, an emeritus professor of anthropology and forced migration at the University of Oxford, highlighted that unlike in Jordan, Syria, and Lebanon, the UN agency for Palestinian refugees, UNRWA, has never operated in Egypt. This absence has meant that education, which often provided hope and economic stability for refugees elsewhere, did not have the same impact in Egypt. Successive Egyptian governments have also rejected naturalizing Palestinians, citing concerns that it could undermine the right of return, a position disputed by rights advocates.

The right of return remains a central point of contention in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Palestinians campaign for the right of all those displaced in 1948 and their descendants to return to their homes, while Israeli governments have consistently rejected the demand, arguing it would overturn the Jewish majority in the state. Despite these political complexities, Abu Hussein remains hopeful, stating that if the community decides to go back, she will join them.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Live Newsline in your inboxYour daily read on the news. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Live Newsline in your inboxYour daily read on the news. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.