AdvertiseDonate
Live Newsline · 1101 West 34th Street, Austin, TX 78705

Climate negotiations stall in Antalya as nations weigh confrontation with Saudi Arabia

Delegates at the Cop31 summit reached a standstill over fossil fuel language, with some countries considering a public showdown to force a decision on the phaseout of oil, gas, and coal.

By Amir Shah ·

Illustration for: Climate negotiations stall in Antalya as nations weigh confrontation with Saudi Arabia
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Climate negotiations reached a stalemate late Saturday night in Antalya, Turkey, as participating nations debated whether to force a direct confrontation with Saudi Arabia and its allies. The core of the dispute centers on the global commitment to phase out fossil fuels, a topic that has become increasingly contentious as the two-week summit extended beyond its scheduled end date.

The joint presidencies of the Cop31 UN climate summit, held by Australia and Turkey, conducted extensive meetings with numerous countries throughout the day and into the evening. Despite these efforts, the talks failed to reach a resolution, leading to growing frustration among both government delegates and environmental campaigners who viewed the lack of progress as a sign of deeper structural issues.

A loose coalition of approximately 130 countries insists on including specific language regarding the transition away from fossil fuels in the final outcome document. Developing nations have also demanded stronger rights to financial support from wealthy countries to help them adapt to the worsening impacts of the climate crisis. These two issues have emerged as the primary obstacles preventing an agreement.

Maina Talia, the climate minister for the Pacific island nation of Tuvalu, described the inclusion of fossil fuel language as a red line for his country. He stated that this issue addresses the root cause of the crisis and that without it, the time spent at the summit would be wasted. This sentiment was echoed by Mohamed Adow of the Power Shift Africa thinktank, who criticized rich countries for finding reasons to avoid delivering promised financial support.

Disagreements also persisted over controversial carbon capture and storage technology, as well as a target to derive 35% of the world's energy from electricity by 2035. Saudi Arabia seeks strong recommendations for this technology in the final decision, while other nations argue it could serve to perpetuate the fossil fuel industry. Some delegates suggested a compromise might be possible if the role of this technology is downplayed in favor of stronger electrification goals.

Campaigners placed the blame for the stalled talks on the fossil fuel industry and the failure of wealthy nations to fulfill financial promises. Nick Dearden of Global Justice Now argued that those profiting from the crisis should no longer hold negotiations to ransom. Harjeet Singh of the Fill the Fund campaign added that developing countries cannot transform their economies while facing disasters and debt, noting that the failure stems from a lack of money and will rather than a lack of solutions.

The summit, originally scheduled to conclude on Friday evening, is likely to continue into Sunday morning. Many delegates have rescheduled their flights home, raising the possibility that the conference could lose the quorum required under the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change if too many participants depart. This procedural risk adds urgency to the ongoing discussions.

The phrase regarding the transition away from fossil fuels was first agreed upon in Dubai in 2023, but progress on implementation was blocked by Saudi Arabia and its allies. At the previous summit in Brazil, hosts pledged to draft a global roadmap for the phaseout. Although this language appeared in a first draft of the current outcome, it was removed from a revised version published on Thursday. On Saturday evening, the EU, the UK, least developed countries, small island states, and many African nations joined forces to demand its reinstatement.

Critics have pointed to the dual presidency as a complicating factor, noting that splitting leadership between Australia and Turkey, two countries with limited traditions in climate diplomacy, may have weakened the process. Claudio Angelo of the Observatorio do Clima suggested that this division contributed to the difficulties in a process already affected by geopolitics. The Guardian reports that an open meeting is under active consideration, which would force Saudi Arabia to publicly state its opposition to the stronger outcome desired by most other nations.

While such a move carries the risk of collapsing the talks, Climate Analytics chief executive Bill Hare believes that if the overwhelming number of countries want a strong text, Saudi Arabia may not stand against the global consensus. China and India, though not formally aligned with the progressive coalition, are also unlikely to block a deal. UK energy minister Miatta Fahnbulleh stated that negotiations remain productive and that a way forward is being sought to secure an agreement that moves the global effort forward.

More World · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Live Newsline in your inboxYour daily read on the news. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Live Newsline in your inboxYour daily read on the news. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.