AdvertiseDonate
Live Newsline · 1101 West 34th Street, Austin, TX 78705

Aged care algorithm scrutiny intensifies as watchdogs demand mandatory audits

Critics warn the government lacks a legal framework to oversee automated decision-making, citing a specific tool that under-assesses support needs for older Australians.

By Daniela Kelly ·

Illustration for: Aged care algorithm scrutiny intensifies as watchdogs demand mandatory audits
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

The Centre for Public Integrity released a report on Thursday warning that the federal government is moving toward a new automated debt scandal without proper checks. The organization, led by chief executive Dr. Catherine Williams, argues that the absence of legislation governing algorithmic decision-making leaves citizens unaware when computer systems shape government outcomes.

The report, titled Computer Says No, examines the use of automated decision-making tools across federal agencies. It includes eight specific recommendations. These call for a public register of all algorithmic uses and a mandatory audit process. The report also proposes an independent body with the power to monitor and investigate government algorithms.

The primary driver for the release was the government’s integrated assessment tool, or IAT. This system determines the level of home support older Australians receive. The IAT has been found to routinely under-assess individuals’ needs. Aged care assessors are currently prohibited from overriding incorrect algorithmic decisions.

Williams stated that the organization became increasingly concerned as evidence emerged regarding the aged care tool. "We have been watching the evidence emerge in relation to the aged care algorithm tool, and becoming increasingly concerned about what is clearly the lack of an appropriate and robust framework to govern use of ADM by the government," Williams said. She added that the situation feels like sleepwalking into another robodebt scenario.

The attorney general’s department has been developing a framework for these tools, with public consultation ending in January 2025. Attorney General Michelle Rowland stated the government is committed to safe and responsible use of these systems. She noted the framework will implement recommendations from the robodebt royal commission. Rowland said the system will embed safeguards and ensure human oversight.

An October report from the Commonwealth Ombudsman found that transparency recommendations from the royal commission were ignored during the IAT rollout. Independent MP Kate Chaney introduced a private member’s bill in September to create a mandatory legislative framework. Chaney noted that the attorney general’s consultation process finished almost two years ago.

Chaney said she has met with the attorney general, who stated the department is still working on the framework. "I think it’s really important that we keep the pressure up so that it doesn’t get dropped because it’s too hard," Chaney said. She emphasized the need for clear pathways for citizens to review automated decisions.

More News · World news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Live Newsline in your inboxYour daily read on the news. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Live Newsline in your inboxYour daily read on the news. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.